Grace-Gonogate: RBZ Deputy chairman Charles Kuwaza responds to Nyarota
On 12 November 2010 The Herald published an article (from The Zimbabwe Mail) by veteran journalist Geoffrey Nyarota on the boardroom squabbles at the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe based on the writer’s research and interviews he had with the bank’s deputy chairman Charles Kuwaza. Kuwaza responds to the article:\r\n
I refer to your story written by Mr Geoff Nyarota, published on the centre page of the Herald on November 12, initially published by The Zimbabwe Mail.
First, I must say that the story you published is full of lies and distortions.
I am surprised and angry that the Editor of The Herald went to print this obnoxious story without seeking comment from me.
Every first-year journalism student at Harare Poly would know that. This is the third time in recent months that journalists at three different publications have failed this simple test of honest and ethical reporting.
This is despite the fact that I am your Chess correspondent in the bi-weekly Sacker column. You have all my contact details — e-mail, mobile and landlines.
If there still is an iota of integrity on your part, you should, in your next issue, reproduce my response in full and give it the same prominence with which you published Mr Nyarota’s.
Here is what I have mailed Mr Nyarota in response to his article.
“You phoned me stating that you had reason to believe that my life was in danger, and you needed, completely off the record, to bring your findings to my attention. You said the matter was urgent, and even mere possession of the information was worrying you.
“I told you I did not ordinarily speak to journalists as some of them had betrayed trust in the past. However, your story was credible because, indeed, somebody had threatened to “sort me out” in the recent past.
“When I met you, you said that my life was in danger because some people were alleging that I had some hand in the story that Swain had published in the Sunday Times of South Africa.
“You said that you had heard that I had been arrested. I confirmed that I had been to the police station to answer certain charges. I told you I had answered those charges to their satisfaction and was released, on the same day on September 29th, not 19th as alleged in your article.
“You then went on to say that certain people were suspecting Gono to be behind the arrest. I told you I did not know, but the police could provide leads if approached.
“You asked whether I had met Swain and I told you I did not know him from a bar of soap. You told me he was an award-winning journalist, alongside with yourself.
“You then asked for my opinion on that article and I told you that I had no particular interest in the matter as it appeared like yellow journalism.
“You then asked if this was the result of infighting in Zanu-PF, and I told you that I had no such knowledge. You asked whether I had any friends among ministers and I told you I had worked with many ministers for 30 years, but none had ever discussed such matters with me.
“You asked about the reputed infighting at the Reserve Bank, and I told you there was no such fighting, that this was the pink Press attempting to elevate ordinary discourse at board level to something newsworthy.
“You asked whether there were any people in Zimbabwe who could be governor, and I commented that, that was a bizarre question, as there were many professionals in the country and elsewhere. I told you that I did not know all people or their capabilities.
“The comments that you add about who was leaking information, were really never put to me, these are your own thoughts which you are trying to give credence to by quoting me as a source.
The “facts, opinions, half-truths, lies, all meshed together to give credence to the story” that you should have referred to, were in relation to the original story of the Sunday Times of September 12, not Swain’s story.
“I asked you again why you thought my life was in danger, but you had no firm details leading to your conclusion. You said you were going to check with some informants, and would come back to me with more specific information on the attempt on my life.
“When you came back, for what you allege to be a second interview, you repeated the story and regurgitated old stories in the Sunday Times. There was nothing new there.
“Whatever happened to journalistic ethics? One of the issues you said you were angry about was Swain’s lack of professionalism, in that he never asked for comments before going to print.
“I never saw your article before you sold it to the highest bidder. You fell into Swain’s trap on the first hurdle.
“I know times are hard, but this is no way to make a living. It seems to me anyone who can pay the piper can ram their thoughtless opinions in national newspapers. This is a zero sum game, which some of us have no time for. Can you imagine the time wasted responding to these scurrilous and purposeless allegations?
“I find your whole conduct lacking integrity. I don’t know who you are working for. The language you use is intemperate, and below the dignity of a man of your experience and reputation (previous).
“In fact, I was concerned whether you were still the same man or something fundamental had changed after your stint in the USA.
“You came pretending to assist me but turned out to be the proverbial wolf. Going backwards to be cub reporter is clearly not a sign of maturity.
“Not having met you before, I noted the slow uptake of issues, repetitions on your part, and wondered whether you were still the same man I had heard of in my youth.
“Eventually, I concluded that you were on a fishing expedition and the “life and death” situation that you had painted was just that, a poor painting. Unfortunately, there was no tiger to catch, not even matemba. Ko aunza mvongamupopoto mumba ndiani?
“Could you find issues which advance the national agenda, seeking progress rather than commit acres of space to worthless skulduggery, something which the youthful reporters from H-Metro could learn from the seasoned journalist that you should be.
“In the meantime, enjoy your 30 pieces of silver.”